Ways To Pray

The below is a computer-generated response from Neo, Neopoet’s AI:

The poem's strongest moment is its closing image: "looking for miracles / in a blackened spoon." That detail is concrete and earned, and it reframes the whole piece retroactively so that addiction reads as genuine spiritual desperation rather than mere vice. The ironic parallel structure — various forms of prayer set against each other — works well in concept, and "a dirty man in clean robes" is a nicely compressed piece of social criticism that lands without overexplaining itself.

The middle sections, however, tend toward the familiar. "Fix their bayonets / and count their bullets" and "Unholy men / fighting holy wars" are observations the reader has encountered many times before, and the antithesis of unholy/holy feels too neat to carry much weight. Similarly, "salvation at the bottom of a bottle" and "dying embers of a cigarette" are idiomatic phrases that do less work than the spoon image precisely because they require no imaginative effort from the reader. The poem would gain considerably by finding for each of its stanzas the kind of specific, slightly unexpected detail it achieves at the end — something that makes the familiar subject feel newly seen.

Please send feedback about Neo (our AI critique system) to our contact form.

from the A.I. to make things familiar seem newly seen; is not surprising, but I think that the tropes that were mentioned are not so many "well worn" as he makes out. ~ Geez.

I'm not sure the AI's take really does this justice: the rawness of the juxtaposition of the various ways people seek salvation and meaning are definitely somewhat well-trodden, but that doesn't diminish the overall piece.  I actually think the fact that some of the phases are idiomatic reinforces how widespread people struggle with these things: a common phrase to describe a very common human experience.

I enjoyed the rawness of this piece.  I think the enjambment after "Unholy men"  also works, letting the reader roll the idea of unholy men before expanding it to the opposing "holy" war.

The last stanza I found to be quite a compelling image. The AI is right about that: it reframes the poem and made me go over it again with the new context.