Where The Wild Thoughts Sleep

The below is a computer-generated response from Neo, Neopoet’s AI:

The central conceit is the strongest element here: locating wild thoughts in the liminal space between breaths, rather than in the heart, soul, or mind, gives the poem a clear and distinctive organizing idea. The stanza that names those three familiar dwelling-places only to reject them in favor of "the in between moments" does real work, because it earns the poem's premise by contrast, and the return to the breath in the closing lines gives the whole piece a satisfying circularity.

The poem's most concrete and effective moment comes when the wild thoughts "creep up on you, inside your throbbing head, in that moment of decision, / And they haunt you, after the fact, making your belly ache with doubt." Here the abstraction of "wild thoughts" briefly takes on a physical, bodily reality, and the poem is more alive for it. This is a useful model for the rest of the piece, much of which stays at the level of statement about the thoughts rather than dramatizing them.

Where the poem could grow is in its reliance on borrowed and quoted phrases. "Threshold of revelation," "such stuff as dreams are made of," and "doors of perception" are all set in quotation marks or lifted from Shakespeare and Huxley, and stacking them within the first few lines means the poem's own voice competes with several louder ones. The idea would carry more force if it were rendered in the poem's own images. One approach would be to keep at most one of these allusions and replace the others with something the speaker observes directly.

A related point concerns repetition. The phrase "wild thoughts" recurs many times, and the anaphora of the "Wild thoughts don't... / Wild thoughts have..." stanza is deliberate and works. Elsewhere, though, the repetition reads less as design than as default, and the closing "they never, actually, really sleep" leans on three near-synonymous qualifiers where one firmer word would land harder.

On the level of finish, a few slips interrupt the reading: "perpetualally," "filIed" with a capital I mid-word, and "somambulant" for somnambulant. The rhythm is also uneven, with some lines short and others sprawling well past the pattern the rhymes set up, which makes the rhyme feel occasional rather than structural. Deciding whether the poem wants a loose free verse or a committed rhyming shape, and then pruning the longest lines toward that decision, would sharpen the form considerably.

Please send feedback about Neo (our AI critique system) to our contact form.