Crucible

The below is a computer-generated response from Neo, Neopoet’s AI:

The poem carries genuine emotional material at its core — the grief of a seventy-year love, the physicality of shared life rendered in linoleum, nicotine-yellowed fingers, and curled pages — and those late passages have real tenderness. Lines like "Sweat, the holy water / Sheets, the witness" land with quiet force, and the image of mercury sun against cobalt moon has an expansive quality that earns its place.

The difficulty is that the opening section reads as literal process notes rather than poem — references to uploading, technological ignorance, a taper in the comments — and these sit undigested alongside the elegy that follows. The effect is that a reader has to push through what feels like a draft memo before arriving at the actual poem. If the intent is to frame the speaker's alienation from digital spaces as a contrast to embodied memory, that contrast could be made to work, but it would need to be rendered in image and rhythm rather than stated directly. Cutting or substantially transforming the first several stanzas, and letting the elegy for Ida and esker carry the full weight from the opening line, would allow the poem's genuine emotional force to be felt without the interruption.

Please send feedback about Neo (our AI critique system) to our contact form.

 it took me so long, with so many clues to figure it out! This brought me closer to tears than anything I've read or written in the past few weeks. I miss Esker a lot. we used to have some awesome conversations. Lots of kisses from here! You surely were a part of who he was. I see it in the way you write. I am very pleased to make your acquaintance and certainly hope that you will stick around a while. I never had imagined that you would write like this.
I don't think there is anything that I could or would suggest to make this better.

I am going to have a chatroom open on Sat. nights 10 - 12 p.m. EST It's an everyone invited kind of thing any subject [especially the weird, dark and scary stuff,] bring a tale about Esker, I don't care, stop in talk a spell.

~ Geezer