Join the Neopoet online poetry workshop and community to improve as a writer, meet fellow poets, and showcase your work. Sign up, submit your poetry, and get started.

A meeting

Once I met a Muslim on a rocky shore.
His skin was brown and his hair dark;
but I was a Christian and  pale...

We eyed each other warily at first,
but then we talked, then swam.

We caught some shellfish
and I took him home
where we cooked paella
and drank white wine.

"But your laws forbid shellfish, " I said
"and wine, too, I believe! "

"Forget such rules, " he replied,
'that's all in theory! "

Soon we were good friends.

Why can't our leaders do that?
— Robert Melliard, Dec 30, 2008

About This Poem

About the Author

Region, Country: Asturias, Spain

Favorite Poets: Chaucer, Shakespeare, Du Bellay, Metaphysicals, Petrarch, Dante, Baudelaire, Lorca, Becquer, Coleridge

More from this author

Critiques

yenti

yenti

17 years 5 months ago

Meeting

this is how people should meet, and talk of many things, (something to do with Walruses) this is how the world should change, but we all know that in humons there is a gain factor that has been bred into most all of us, by Religion and other things. Offence is usually taken by people that avoid understanding others. Have a great New Year Yours Ian.T
Robert Melliard

Robert Melliard

17 years 5 months ago

Thanks for your comment

I'm glad you seem to tune in to the message of this poem. I used to play cricket with Indians, Pakistanis, Jamaicans and Africans, and we got on fine. The only problem was that we Brits had taught them all the secrets of that mysterious game (and they could play it all year round where they lived) so they usually won! I have also been lucky enough to travel a little, and have met many people of other religions and colours without feeling any tension. (The big exception was Thailand, though I think the guys I came up against there were not native Thais - see my short story Thai Rack if interested.) With Indians (from India I mean) in particular, I even seem to experience some weird sense of identification. If you liked this poem you might also be interested in 'Colours'. Best Wishes, Robert.
ID

Ink Dragon

17 years 5 months ago

Robert,

I was not aware that the Koran forbids shellfish, I thought it was only the Torah that forbade it... Anyway, an astute observation you made there: When we get to know a person, we should be able to lay our prejudices aside. I second your wish for our leaders trying that, Ink
Robert Melliard

Robert Melliard

17 years 5 months ago

The Koran and th Torah

You may well be right on that point. This meeting happened many years ago, and I probably drank a little too much as well, so my memory of that dinner isn't too clear. But I think you have understood the main idea. Perhaps I can rephrase the poem in some way so that it doesn't specifically mention the Koran, using an expression like 'Muslim law' or 'Muslim rules' or 'your faith' instead. Thanks for commenting. Best Wishes, Robert.
Barbara Writes

Barbara Writes

17 years 5 months ago

Robert

Great write i love the theme and the message. It is one of truth. I have a friend we are of different race, background and many people find her offensive, but not me and I got some crap for it at first. Couldn't care less. We talked and she share with me how people treat her because they misinterpret her. She even adopted a infant of another race. Her actions is what I look at not her imperfect background that shape her personality. She has a good heart and we carpooled back and forth to ASL classes because both our husband did not want us traveling alone at night out of town for a seven week class. Her conversation with me one night was one I realize she was trying to tell me she was not like her family. I stopped her by reassuring her that none of that matter and she do not offend me because i too have issue and offend people unintentional. When people say things about her in a judgmental way and I defend her every time because she never haft to change for me because we stay true to ourself when around each other. Respectfully Yours, Barbara
Robert Melliard

Robert Melliard

17 years 5 months ago

I thank you truly

I thank you truly for the insight that your offer. Individuals should not be conditioned by race, religion or family expectations. They should try to discover their natural personality and talents and use them for the best. The problem is that I only discovered mine quite late in life, and I think that happens to many of us. It sounds as if you have a true friend, and you are also a loyal friend to her. Thanks for your comment and I am glad you enjoyed this memory. Best Wishes, Robert. .
L

Lonnie

17 years 5 months ago

Would that it could be!

A fine, Idealistic, thought here, Robert! I just wish that it could indeed be so! Things would be so much simpler!
Robert Melliard

Robert Melliard

17 years 5 months ago

Hell, Lonnie, it CAN be so!

The problem at present is that we do not educate our god-dam leaders properly! I shall be posting a poem on this subject as soon as this blog will let me!! The only thing you have to do to become a Government Minister or even a President is go to all the god-dam party-political meetings and have the necessary back-up!!! Why don't we demand that they obtain a degree in International Relations, travel a bit, know where Mexico is, and maybe even study a little economics, too????? Hell, we're talking about well-paid jobs!!!! PLEASE READ MY NEXT POEM!!!!!!! Best Wishes, Robert. P.S. Sincere thanks for your comment, and I thoroughly respect your opinion, especially as you fought for freedom, according to one of your poems... P.P.S. I might not have got on so well with Saddam Hussein if I had met him on that rocky shore, but then he was a god-dam politician! P.P.S Is it O.K. to say 'god-dam' on this blog? If not, I apologize. Please remember I'm a Brit, so I don't know how taboo 'god-dam' is. In fact I've never used the god-dam word before in my life, but as I'm talking to a god-dam American (whose father probably helped us through the Second World War) I feel obliged to adapt to American English...
infinite_dwarf

infinite_dwarf

17 years 5 months ago

Robert

An interesting thought, and quite a fellow you came across! Most live and die by scripture, and would not even think about disobeying it in any way. ~Jess K. ---------------------------------------------------- - "If we always give what we have always given, we will always get what we have always got..." - Mike R.
Robert Melliard

Robert Melliard

17 years 5 months ago

The scriptures

I met this guy in what used to be called Yugoslavia, where I had been allowed to stay in a friend's home on the coast. I believe that in certain areas of that country Muslims, Jews and Christians lived together in peace for centuries. That's why their civil war was such a tragedy. This particular man was clearly not a Taliban. I believe that strict religion tends to take over where poverty and lack of education leave little alternative hope in most people's lives, which may be the case in Afghanistan, for example. The best way to get rid of extremism might be to simply improve standards of living there. Personally I am a rather lax Christian in my way of life, and could probably do better if I drank less wine. Shellfish is out for me right now due to high cholesterol, but I used to love it. Someone once told me that shellfish and pork were originally forbidden because they could easily go off in hot weather, and were therefore dangerous to eat, so there may be a little logic behind some of these religious prohibitions. In India, the theory was that if poor families killed their cow to eat the meat, they would no longer have milk the following month, nor dung to cook with (in a country where firewood is scarce). Hence the sacred cow. If you are interested in the basic thought behind this poem, please read my next one, which will be called A Formula For Peace and will go into the two main subjects of this poem (accepting human diversity and not accepting inadequate leadership) in more detail. Thanks for your comment. Best Wishes, Robert.
R

R.M.Shanmugam

17 years 5 months ago

surprisingly a short one,

surprisingly a short one, again a story. a good question asked in it.
Robert Melliard

Robert Melliard

17 years 5 months ago

Short or long poems

Many thanks for your succinct comment. I used to write mostly shorter poems, in fact my only published book ('This Day's a Diamond') contains poems almost exclusively less than a page in length. But for some reason, since I joined Neopoet, my thoughts have begun to flow more freely, and I now seem to be writing just as many long pieces as short ones. Perhaps this is due to the effect of reading so many poems by other members of this blog, each with their own particular way of expressing thoughts and feelings, and also to the stimulating exchange of ideas involved in replying to readers' comments. Best Wishes, Robert.
Y

youarehere

17 years 5 months ago

For the Love of Paella!

If paella can't heal religio-cultural wounds, we're all doomed. This is a beauitful poem. There seems to be a qaulity in all of your poetry...a way that depth and metaphor shimmer through concrete experience. This poem also reminds me of an early verison of the Grail Romance...forgive me for not taking the time in the moment to chase down names and citations...but there is a knight of mixed Islamic and English ethnicity who falls in love with a woman. Without a second thought he changes his religious affilation to gain her love. He understands the difference between religion and spirituality and that love is a unifying force that transcends differences. I have always felt that peace is not the absence of conflict (which others have said) but the love of differences. I wish we understood, as your poem beautifully expresses, that we gain something when we're able to sacrifice our sacred cows. Perhaps if we create an international chain of tapas bars and paella establishments for the sake of schooling our leaders...? For me, the last line is too pedantic. It is significantly less transluscent than the rest of your peom. I would rather have your words continue to open my heart instead of wag its finger at the end of the poem. Perhaps something along the lines of, "I will prepare this meal for the House of Lords." or some such sentiment involving some governemental figure or group? I'd prepare the meal for George W. Bush, nut he'd proabably put catsup on it, choke, and trade in his white wine for bad beer. Michael
Robert Melliard

Robert Melliard

17 years 5 months ago

What a comment!

Both comments I have received from you about my poems are exceptionally long and interesting, so many thanks. I thoroughly agree with your idea that 'peace...is the love of differences'. The grail story is fascinating, too. It reminded me of when I fell in love with a Mexican girl (see my poem called 'Colours' if interested) because although we were both Christians, she was a Catholic and I was a Protestant, and there were big differences between our cultural backgrounds. Also, I spoke no Spanish at that time (nor she English) so we had to overcome some big barriers, but we managed to do that in just a few hours. I understand your doubts about the last line, and will be thinking about it over the next few days. I love your final joke about catsup and bad beer. I once took an American businessman (then my boss) to a good restaurant here in Asturias, where they specialized in exquisite local fish, lightly grilled with a little chopped garlic, fresh parsley and olive oil. When he asked for some catsup, the expression on the waiter's face was one of pure disdain, and it turned out that they didn't even have any catsup on the premises (presumably because no Spanish customer would dream of making such a request when the food was so good on its own). I suppose the waiter saw it as an insult to the chef. Best wishes, Robert. P.S. I am glad you have tuned in to the 'concrete experience' element in my poems, which are almost always based on something that really happened to me or to someone I know, however strange the story may sound. I tend to think I've had a rather weird life, though I suppose odd things happen to all of us from time to time...
Janice Pearce

Janice Pearce

17 years 5 months ago

A Meeting

A great lesson in just one line Robert. I enjoyed it, thanks for sharing! _____________________________ To write a touching poem, you must gently stir the soul, if it brings forth tears or smiles, then the story was beautifully told. ________Janice Pearce_________