Join the Neopoet online poetry workshop and community to improve as a writer, meet fellow poets, and showcase your work. Sign up, submit your poetry, and get started.

A Loving Sin

Is this Love
what I feel for you?
But I know
that I love him, too

I never wish
to give him pain
But can't resist
your love, it's plain

Is it a sin
to love two at a time?
My head spins
Want to shut my mind
— Nilmini, Nov 12, 2008

About This Poem

About the Author

Country/Region: LKA

More from this author

Critiques

B

barbsdad2003

17 years 6 months ago

A life's dilemma ...

you portray here well. As far as it goes. Seems incomplete somehow. I read an earlier write of yours and understand the connection between the two, that one/this one. May I suggest a couple things that might contribute balance as to line length(s). As to: My head spins Want to shut my mind, perhaps make it My head, it spins I want to shut my mind (Or: I want to close my mind) The overall brevity's a plus. The apparent subtle confusion extant in the piece is consistent with the self-questioning subject matter. Another plus. Although at this time I don't want to offer more, I think a revisit by you, in terms of some amount of tweaking, might strengthen ... Perhaps a note of indirection may help, as in to hint. To state boldly often weakens a poem; whereas to walk around the subject, allude to it, color it with metaphor/simile ... all can make it stronger, more potent. Another problem encountered with this kind of subject matter is that it's so well trod through history. It's hard to compete with so many who've priorly written on the same or similar subject(s)/quandary(ies). Regards, Chuck
Nilmini

Nilmini

17 years 6 months ago

Thanks Chuck

This is exactly the type of comments I looked forward to. I appreciate your suggestions and hope that I will get some more comments, so that I may make my mind up on how to change this work. Thanks so much for your lavishly used kind words that kept me in high spirit. I will for sure take into account your advice about saying things less boldly. I know I have to improve a lot. Hope you will read my other work as well & help me in improving my self! Best Regards, Nilmini
W

Wafi

17 years 6 months ago

A Very

A very well written and clearly portraying.And a difficult situation to handle. Enjoyed it.Thanks for sharing. Wafi
Nilmini

Nilmini

17 years 6 months ago

Wafi

Thank you so much for reading & commenting. I'm pleased that I shared my feelings with you. Best Regards Nilmini
ML

Michael Landau

17 years 6 months ago

The rhyming is very good.

The rhyming is very good in the first two stanzas, but in the last stanza I don't really feel like time rhymes that well with mind. I was thinking maybe you could change the last stanza to say the following: Is it a sin to love two in these times? My head spins and my heart resigns I know that you probably won't like it because it considerably changes the meaning of the last stanza, but I thought I would suggest it to see what you thought about it. I'm not good with technical details, I just write what sounds good to me. If you don't like my suggestion, I completely understand. Sincerely, Michael
Nilmini

Nilmini

17 years 6 months ago

Michael

Thank you for your good comments Michael. I know 'time' doesn't rhyme well with 'mind'. But I wanted my initial idea to be put in the 3rd stanza. My question was whether it's wrong to have loving feelings towards two persons at the same time. If I change the line into " ..to love two in these times?", I feel that my real problem won't be shown there. However, I wish I could do a better job in here. Nevertheless, I like your line with "...my heart resigns". It give's some what similar idea to my last line, although what I meant there, was that I wanted to stop thinking, because the current confusion is way too much to bear. Thanks again Michael & I hope that you'll keep helping me in improving myself in this art in which I'm really poor. Warmest Regards, Nilmini